Comment décider entre le sablage et le remplacement d'un plancher ancien?
Reading time: 4'

How to decide between sanding and replacing an old floor?

Deciding Between Floor Sanding and Replacement for an Old Floor: The Comprehensive Guide

When it comes to renovating an old floor, a crucial question arises: should you opt for floor sanding or a complete floor replacement? Each of these options has its own advantages and disadvantages, and it's essential to make an informed decision to ensure the best aesthetic and functional outcome for your space. In this article, we will guide you through the key factors to consider when making this important decision.

Floor Sanding: Refreshing the Past with Elegance

Floor sanding is a proven technique for restoring the beauty of an old floor. This method involves sanding the top layer of wood to remove scratches, stains, and signs of wear and tear. Here are the advantages of floor sanding:

  1. Cost-effective: Floor sanding is generally more cost-effective than a complete floor replacement. It allows you to breathe new life into your floor without the high costs associated with purchasing new materials.

  2. Durability: Wooden floors often have exceptional durability. By sanding your floor, you can extend its lifespan by many years, even decades.

  3. Preservation of Character: If you have an old floor with a history, sanding allows you to preserve its authentic character while making it more appealing.

  4. Finish Options: After sanding, you have the option to choose from a variety of finishes, from varnish to staining, to achieve the exact look you desire.

When to Choose Floor Sanding?

Floor sanding is ideal in the following situations:

  • Your floor is in good structural condition but shows signs of wear and tear.

  • You want to preserve the authentic character of your floor.

  • You are looking for a more budget-friendly solution compared to a complete replacement.

However, it's important to note that floor sanding is not always the suitable solution. In some cases, floor replacement may be the best option.

Floor Replacement: Total Transformation

A complete floor replacement involves removing the old floor and installing a new one. Here are the advantages of this option:

  1. Customized Design: Floor replacement gives you the opportunity to choose an entirely new design and customize your space.

  2. Modern Solutions: If your old floor is in poor condition or no longer meets your needs, replacement can be the solution to incorporate modern technologies, such as underfloor heating.

  3. Problem Elimination: If your floor has significant structural issues, replacement may be necessary to ensure the safety of your space.

When to Opt for Floor Replacement?

Floor replacement is recommended in the following situations:

  • Your floor is severely damaged or structurally weakened.

  • You want a major aesthetic update for your space.

  • You need to integrate modern features, such as underfloor heating.

  • The cost of replacement is justified by the aesthetic and functional benefits.

How to Make Your Decision?

The decision between floor sanding and floor replacement depends on several factors. Here are some steps to help you choose:

  1. Assessment of Current Condition: Have your floor inspected by a professional to evaluate its condition. This will help you determine if it can be effectively restored through sanding.

  2. Design Goals: Consider the aesthetic you want to achieve. If you have a specific vision in mind, replacement may be the best option.

  3. Budget: Determine your available budget. While floor sanding is often more economical, if you have the means and the replacement is justified, it's worth considering.

  4. Functionality: If your floor has structural problems, safety and functionality should take priority. In this case, replacement may be necessary.


The decision between floor sanding and floor replacement for an old floor depends on several factors, including the current condition of the floor, your aesthetic and functional goals, and your budget. Floor sanding is often a cost-effective option to refresh a floor while preserving its character, while replacement allows for a complete transformation of the space. Before making your final decision, consult a flooring professional for advice specific to your situation. Whichever option you choose, make sure to work with flooring experts like Plancher Deluxe to achieve the best possible results.

Leave a comment

Please note, comments need to be approved before they are published.